the question is simple: what is your favorite peanut butter? i am specifically interested in no-stir varieties, but other than that i'm not fussy. we've been getting maranatha no-stir for quite awhile now, but the last few jars we've bought have been oddly soupy (for no-stir) and i'm vaguely frustrated by that.
today i bought some whole foods 365 organic something or other, and we'll give that a shot to see what we think. i believe it's the one that used to be the "whole kids" variety, which they stopped making (but merely re-labeled), but i'm not totally sure about that. it's what i was hoping to get, but there were like six different kinds of 365 peanut butter (no salt! unsweetened! red label! blue label!), so i can't be positive.
i used to be a die-hard jif girl; seriously, from birth. i'm pretty proud of myself for successfully switching to a more natural brand, but i really really really want non-soupy no-stir. creamy or crunchy, makes no difference to me. peanut butter is an absolute staple in this house, so i'd love any input if you've got it!